Monday, October 24, 2011

Post-training muscle cooling may attenuate training effects

Today, I would like to comment more on a point I made few weeks ago in a post on cryotherapy after training (http://georgenassis.blogspot.com/2011/07/some-thoughts-on-use-of-water-immersion.html). Please let me remind you that cryotherapy is used by many athletes as a means to minimize muscle damage and muscle soreness and thus speed up recovery after hard training and game. In my latest post I set the hypothesis that cryotherapy-induced reduction in muscle damage and inflammation might suppress training adaptations.


One of the blog reader emailed  me the paper by Yamane et al (1996) published in European Journal of Applied Physiology. In their study, researchers had their subjects cool one leg and arm with water immersion after training whereas the other limb was the control (no cooling). One group performed arm strength training and the other endurance cycling training. Training was performed 3-4 times per week for 4-6 weeks.




Did cryotherapy improve performance more that the control?
No. In this study, control and cooled legs improved endurance performance time at similar degree. However, maximal oxygen uptake was improved only in the control leg. In addition, maximal arm strength was improved at a significantly greater magnitude in the control than in the cooled arms group.

Take-home message
I am not saying that cryotherapy is not good for recovery. There are a lot of data in the literature suggesting that cryotherapy might speed up, at least, the perception of effort by athletes. If you feel good you perform well in the next session. If you perform well you gain more adaptations. However, from this study it appears that the effect of cryotherapy on LONG-TERM training-induced adaptations requires further investigation.



Reference
Yamane et al. (2006). Post-exercise leg and forearm flexor muscle cooling in humans attenuates endurance and resistance training effects on muscle performance and on circulatory adaptations. Eur J Appl Physiol 96: 572-580.

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Carbohydrate ingestion in training and game: why is needed?


A large amount of research suggests carbohydrate (CHO) ingestion either in liquid or solid form prior to and during prolonged exercise that lasts more than 1 hour. Limited information exists regarding the role of this strategy on performance in intermittent exercise such as football. From these studies, it appears that carbohydrate ingestion before and during exercise improves intermittent endurance capacity. Although there are no scientific data, I speculate that total distance covered and distance covered at moderate/high intensity should be improved with carbohydrate ingestion. From published research, it seems that sprint performance remains unaffected by CHO ingestion.


It is noteworthy that football skills seem to be affected by CHO ingestion. Ajmol Ali and Clyde Williams from the University of Loughborough asked 17 players to perform a football-specific intermittent test and also evaluated skill performance under two experimental conditions: 1) following ingestion of a CHO-electrolyte solution before and every 15min during the test, 2) following ingestion of a placebo solution of equivalent taste and volume. Their results showed a 17% reduction in skill performance during the control trial. This reduction was only 3% in the CHO trial. Thus, it seems that carbohydrate ingestion during exercise may maintain football skill performance during the game.

What is the mechanism behind performance improvement?
Football skill maintenance with carbohydrate ingestion could be due to direct effect of CHO in the central nervous system. Indeed, recent studies show that CHO when in the mouth may activate brain regions that are involved in reward and motor control (Chambers et al., 2009). There are two more explanations for the positive effect of CHO ingestion on intermittent running performance:  a) the sparing of muscle glycogen, b) the maintenance of blood glucose, although hypoglycemia is not usually presented in running.



Table. Effect of carbohydrate ingestion prior and during exercise that simulates football on performance.

Sprint
Endurance capacity
Skills
Decision-making
Effect
No effect
Positive
Positive
Positive
Level of evidence
5
5
3
3
Level of evidence ranges from 1 (very low) to 5 (very strong)



Is it safe for youth players?
Yes, it is. There is no study to suggest that youth players should not ingest carbohydrate solutions. Recent studies show that carbohydrate ingestion either in a beverage or gel improves intermittent endurance capacity in young players (Phillips et al., 2011a; Phillips et al., 2011b).

What to drink, how much and at what time?
-You can drink carbohydrate solutions before (150-250ml for 80kg body weight) and during exercise (at regular intervals when it is possible). Players should try to consume 50-60 g CHO per hour.
-It is better to drink solutions than contain 2-7% CHO or 20-70 gr CHO per liter.
-Commercially available carbohydrate drinks contain electrolytes. Electrolytes a) improve the drink’s taste, b) speed glucose entry into the bloodstream.
-Recent studies suggest that adding some protein may improve more endurance capacity compared with the CHO-electrolyte solution (Alghannam, 2011).
-Choose the drink temperature you like. Drink temperature must be mild and not too low (<5oC)
-It is not easy for the players to ingest beverages or solid CHO before a game or at half-time. EXPERIMENT YOUR STRATEGY BEFORE USING IT IN THE GAME.
-Do not overdo it. If you drink too much you might get stomach discomfort.


For additional reading
Ali and Williams (2009). Carbohydrate ingestion and soccer skill performance during prolonged intermittent exercise. J Sports Sci 27(14):1499-1508.

Alghannam (2011). Carbohydrate-protein ingestion improves subsequent running capacity towards the end of a football-specific intermittent exercise. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 36(5):748-57.

Chambers et al. (2009). Carbohydrate sensing in the human mouth: effects on exercise performance and brain activity. J Physiol 587:1779-94.

Nassis et al (1998). Effect of a carbohydrate-electrolyte drink on endurance capacity during prolonged intermittent high intensity running. Br J Sports Med 32(3):248-252.

Phillips et al. (2011). Carbohydrate ingestion during team games exercise: current knowledge and areas for future investigation. Sports Med 41(7):559-585.


Sunday, October 16, 2011

Speed, agility, quickness (SAQ) training method: what’s new?

Performance in football depends among others on the ability to react fast, take fast steps, be quick in the first 5 m, and make fast movements in changing directions. All this happens in an unpredictable way for a period of at least 90min. Thus football players need to undertake strength, power, balance, speed, agility and endurance training. This makes conditioning planning a complex process.

Today, I would like to comment only on the speed, agility, quickness training. This is the so called SAQ training method. Unfortunately, there are no many scientific studies on SAQ method in elite football players. One of them is that recently published by Jovanovic and colleagues (2011). In this study, high level junior players were divided into two groups: the control group that did regular training Monday to Friday and one game each Saturday and the experimental group. Players in this group supplemented their regular training with 3 SAQ training sessions a week (Monday, Wednesday and Thursday morning for 90-120min each).





After 8 weeks of SAQ training, players showed

  • 2,1% improvement in 5m time (Quickness)
  • 3,7% improvement in 10m run (acceleration) 
  • 1% improvement in counter-movement jump (power)
No improvement in these fitness parameters were seen in the control group.


Conclusions
1)     SAQ training is effective in improving fitness in high-level players.
2)     To improve these factors coaches should plan SAQ training at least 3 times per week for 90-120 min each session.
3)     The improvement with SAQ training seems to be due to adaptations taking place in the central nervous system and the muscle itself.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

A soccer-specific neuromuscular training program to reduce injuries in young players

In a study published last year by Emery and Meeuwisse (2010) from the University of Calgary, Canada, the effect of a soccer-specific neuromuscular training on injury rate was examined in 13-18 years old players. 750 players were split in two groups: the neuromuscular training group and the control group. Players in the first group supplemented their regular training with a neuromuscular training program performed before training. Players in the control group did only regular training. The program was for 20 weeks.

Neuromuscular training included:
-15min warm up
-10min of neuromuscular training with body weight
-15min of balance training using a wobble board

Some of the exercises are presented in figures 1-4 below (pictures are from Emery and Meeuwisse, 2010, Br J Sport Med).






Main findings
-Injury rate was almost half in the neuromuscular training group compared with the control group. In particular, the overall injury rate in the neuromuscular training group was 2.08 injuries/1000 player-hours and 3.35 injuries/1000 player-hours in the control group.

-Rates of ankle and knee sprains were lower in the neuromuscular training group compared with the control group.

CONCLUSION AND PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
It seems that this neuromuscular training program reduces the risk of ankle and knee sprain injuries in youth players.

Cristiano Ronaldo tested for skills

Monday, October 10, 2011

Cristiano Ronaldo tested for mental ability

Be at the right place at the right moment to make the right action


So far, I have written a lot on the physiological aspects of modern football. Today I would like to deal with some key tactical aspects and support my words with scientific evidence.

At the elite level, it seems that differences between players during the game are more related to tactics, motivation and specific technical skills. Tactical skills refer to the quality of the player to adopt the right action at the right moment.


 












Is there scientific evidence behind it?
In a study published last year, researchers from the University of Groningen, The Netherlands, evaluated tactical skills in 105 elite youth players who participated in the their club’s talent development program at the start of the project (around 16-18 years of age) and at adulthood (21 years or older). At the adulthood, players were grouped as amateurs (2nd national division or lower) and professionals (those playing either with a premier league club or on the first team of the 1st division of the national league). Tactical skills were assessed with a specific questionnaire. Among others the scales “Positioning” and “Deciding” were evaluated.

Their results showed that those player scoring “good” to “excellent” in the “Positioning” and “Deciding”  at the age of 16-18 years were almost 7 times more likely to reach the professional level that those scoring in the lowest categories.

It seems that besides physical fitness, the ability to be at the right place at the right moment to make the right action is a key factor that differentiates between professional and amateur players.


Practical applications
We could add subscales “Positioning” and “Deciding” to our talent identification program.

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Cristiano Ronaldo: what makes a top performer?


Cristiano Ronaldo is not only a fantastic player but a top athlete as well. He presents the right mixture of football skills with football-specific athletic performance.


The series of videos that will be posted show some of the performance tests of Cristiano Ronaldo.

Video 1 is on speed and agility testing.

Saturday, October 8, 2011

How to estimate maturity in young players

Power, strength and endurance are all important aspects of physical fitness in top level football. In pre-pubertal boys these parameters are affected not from chronological but biological age. This explains the large variation in performance between pre-pubertal boys of similar chronological age.

Indeed, biological age is associated with hormonal changes that affect performance. For instance, puberty in males is associated with elevated testosterone concentration. High testosterone levels in the blood stream will increase muscle and heart size and this will result in sprint, jump and endurance improvements. Thus, the estimation of biological age or maturity level is important to talent identification and development in modern football.

Methods for maturity estimation
-x-ray of the fingers, hand and wrist: A hand is easily x-rayed with minimal radiation and shows many bones in a single view. The bones in the x-ray are compared to the bones of a standard atlas. This is the “gold standard” method that also can be used for height prediction with an acceptable accuracy.

-anthropometry: this is an indirect method based on certain simple anthropometric measures. It is a practical method predicting years from peak height velocity age (maturity offset value).

The equation is
Maturity offset= -9.236 + 0.0002708 (leg length X sitting height) - 0.001663 (age X leg length) + 0.007216 (age X sitting height) + 0.02292 (weight/height)

To read more on skeletal age in football please visit
Nassis G. Do talented players become elite adults? http://www.bmj.com/content/338/bmj.b490/reply


Tuesday, October 4, 2011

How to increase first step speed in football players


Strength and in particular power are important fitness components in modern football. This is because short sprints averaging 2-4 seconds might be decisive of the match result. Looking at the match analysis data, a 2-4 sec sprint occurs every 90 sec. In addition, more than 95% of sprints are shorter than 30 m and almost half of them are shorter than 10 m. It seems therefore that velocity attained in less than 10 m run and even velocity during the first step are very important fitness components.

To maximize these abilities players need to improve power. This can be done with conventional strength training, plyometric exercises and a combination of both. Let me remind you that plyometric exercises involve stretching the muscle immediately before making a rapid concentric contraction. Indeed, some studies have shown an improvement in sprint time and jumping in football players after 7-8 weeks of plyometric training.


In a recent study, Chelly and colleagues (2010) examined if plyometric training would enhance performance in young experienced players. 19 years old players were divided into the experimental and the control group. The experimental group supplemented its regular football training with plyometric exercises, 2 times per week for 8 weeks in-season.

Weekly plyometric training consisted of

-40 to 60-cm hurdle jumps X10 reps X 5-10 sets in the first 4 weeks
-40-cm drop jumpsX10 reps X 5-10 sets in the following 4 weeks

Main findings
-velocity during the first step improved by 18% with plyometric training and only 9% with regular football training

-velocity in the first 5-m of sprint improved by 10% with plyometric training and only 3% with regular training

-Maximum sprinting velocity improved by 9% with plyometric training and only 2,5% with regular training

-vertical jump improved by 2,5 % with plyometric training, no change with regular training

CONCLUSION AND PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
In-season hurdle and drop jumps performed 2 times a week for 8 weeks can improve first step speed and enhance sprinting  to a greater extent than regular football training in young, experienced players.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Beta alanine supplementation: does it improve performance?


Fatigue at certain points of the game or training is related, among other factors, to the high concentration of H+ in the muscle which can limit the ability of muscle contraction. Thus, any intervention that can reduce the rate of intracellular H+ accumulation during high intensity exercise would increase performance.

Physiological role of β-alanine
Carnosine is a cytoplasmic dipeptide found in skeletal muscles and in the central nervous system. One of the physiological effects of carnosine is to buffer H+. Muscle carnosine is formed by bonding histidine and beta (β)-alanine and previous studies have shown an increase in muscle carnosine concentration after long term β-alanine supplementation.



Recent findings
In a recent study, Sale et al. (2011) from the Nottingham Trent University, UK, had their subjects perform an anaerobic test before and after 4 weeks of either β-alanine supplementation (6.4 gr/day) or placebo intake. Their results showed a 16% improvement in performance during the anaerobic test that lasted 150 sec. Although this is different to what happens in football we can assume that β-alanine supplementation may enhance anaerobic performance in football players.

To my knowledge there is only one study using a football specific protocol (repeated sprints on the treadmill). In this study, physically active men performed 2 sets of  5x5-sec sprints with 45sec recovery after 5 weeks of β-alanine supplementation (Sweeney et al., 2010). Their results showed no effect of β-alanine supplementation on repeated sprints abillity.

The findings of these studies seem contradictory. To my point of view this is not the case. From these and other studies in the literature it seems that β-alanine supplementation may enhance performance during exercise bouts that stress lactic acid production and lactic acid accumulation. When exercise, as in the case of the study by Sweeney et al. (2010) above, does not result in high lactate and thus H+ accumulation β-alanine has no effect on performance. No doubt that more research, in particular on football players is needed before reach a conclusion.

One more point. There is strong evidence that β-alanine supplementation a) reduces body fat, and b) increases muscle strength. Both effects have applications to football training and performance.


What is the effective strategy?
The effective protocol seems to be the ingestion of 6.4 gr/day β-alanine for 4 weeks. Tablets should be consumed at 4 equal doses at 3 to 4 hours intervals.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Physiology of small-sided games: what's new?


Koklu et al. Comparison of the physiological responses to different small-sided games in elite young soccer players. J Strength Cond Res. 2011 25(6):1522-8.


 The purpose of this study was to compare the blood lactate (La), heart rate (HR) and percentage of maximum HR (%HRmax) responses among the small-sided games (SSGs) in elite young soccer players. Sixteen players (average age 15.7 6 0.4 years; VO2max 53.1 6 5.9 ml /kg/min) volunteered to perform the Yo-Yo intermittent recovery test and 6 bouts of soccer drills including 1-a-side, 2-a-side, 3-a-side, and 4-a-side games without a goalkeeper in random order at 2-day intervals. Significant differences were found on La, HR, and %HRmax among the bouts. The 3-a-side and 4-a-side games were significantly higher than 1-a-side and 2-a-side games on HR and %HRmax, whereas the 1-a-side game significantly resulted in higher La responses compared to other SSGs. This study demonstrated that physiological responses during the 1-a-side and 2-a-side games were different compared to 3-a-side and 4-a-side games. Therefore, it can be concluded that a decreased number of players results in increased intensity during SSGs including 6 bouts. These results suggest that coaches should pay attention on choosing the SSG type and the number of bouts to improve desired physical conditioning of elite young soccer players in soccer training.


Da Silva et al. Exercise intensity and technical demands of small-sided games in young Brazilian soccer players: effect of number of players, maturation, and reliability. J Strength Cond Res. 2011 Sep 8. [Epub ahead of print]

The aims of this study were to examine in young soccer players (a) the effect of varying the number of players on exercise intensity (EI) and technical actions during small-sided games (SSGs), (b) the reliability of EI and technical actions, and (c) the influence of the players' maturation on EI and involvements with the ball (IWBs). Sixteen male soccer players (mean ± SD; age 13.5 ± 0.7 years) completed 2 bouts of 3 vs. 3 (SSG3), 4 vs. 4 (SSG4), and 5 vs. 5 (SSG5) training. Exercise intensity was measured using heart rate and expressed as a percentage of maximal heart rate (%MHR). Technical actions were quantified from video recordings. Maturation stage was determined with the Tanner scale. Exercise intensity in SSG3 (89.8 ± 2%MHR) was higher than that in SSG5 (86.9 ± 3%MHR). The EI in the first set (86.8 ± 4%MHR) was lower than that in the second (89.1 ± 3%MHR) and in the third set (89.4 ± 3%MRH). No effects of number of players were found in IWB, passes, target passes, tackles, and headers. Significantly more crosses, dribbling, and shots on goal were observed during SSG3 compared to during SSG4 or SSG5. The level of maturation was not correlated with either EI or IWB. These results extend previous findings with adult players suggesting that SSGs can provide an adequate training stimulus for young players and are feasible for groups with heterogeneous maturation levels.


Dellal et al. Effect of the number of ball contacts within bouts of 4 vs. 4 small-sided soccer games. Int J Sports Physiol Perform. 2011, 6(3):322-33.

 

The aim of this study was to examine the influence of the number of ball touches authorized per possession on the physical demands, technical performances and physiological responses throughout the bouts within 4 vs. 4 soccer small-sided games (SSGs). Twenty international soccer players (27.4 ± 1.5 y) performed three different 4 vs. 4 SSGs (4 × 4 min) in which the number of ball touches authorized per possession was manipulated (1 touch = 1T; 2 touches = 2T; Free Play = FP). The SSGs were divided in 4 bouts (B1, B2, B3 and B4) separated by 3 min of passive recovery. The physical performances, technical activities, heart rate responses, blood lactate and RPE were analyzed.
The FP rule presented greater number of duels, induced the lowest decreases of the sprint and high-intensity performances, and affected less the technical actions (successful passes and number of ball losses) from B1 to B4 as compared with 1T and 2T forms. Moreover, the SSG played in 1T form led to reach higher solicitation of the high-intensity actions while players presented more difficulty to perform a correct technical action.
In conclusion, the modification of the number of ball touches authorized per possession affects the soccer player activity from the first to the last bout of SSG, indicating that the determination of this rule has to be precisely planned by the coach according to the objectives of the training.

Saturday, September 24, 2011

Tear fluid analysis: a new assessment technique in sports science?

Human tears are a complex solution consisting mainly of water and electrolytes. Tear fluid has been reported to be isotonic with plasma. Accordingly, measurement of tear osmolarity has been used as a tool to evaluate hydration status in clinical studies. Its reliability however was relatively low due mainly to a) large sample variability, b) evaporation of tear fluids in the time elapsed between tear collection and analysis (3-5min).

Recently, a portable, noninvasive tear collection and analysis device has been produced. Its advantages are a) small tear volume required (50 nanoliter), b) very short time for tear collection (<5sec) and analysis (10 sec). The validity of the new device to track hydration level in athletes was tested in a study published in Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise August 2011 by Fortes et al.



Figure. The new tear collection and analysis device (TearLab).

The aim of this study was to compare changes in Tear osmolarity (Tosm) and another widely used noninvasive marker, urine specific gravity (USG), with changes in Plasma osmolarity (Posm) during hypertonic-hypovolemia. In a randomized order, 14 healthy volunteers exercised in the heat on one occasion with fluid restriction (FR) until 1%, 2%, and 3% body mass loss (BML) and with overnight fluid restriction until 08:00 h the following day, and on another occasion with fluid intake (FI).

Posm and USG increased with progressive dehydration on FR. Tosm increased significantly on FR from 293 ± 9 to 305 ± 13 mOsm·L(-1) at 3% BML and remained elevated overnight (304 ± 14 mOsm·L(-1); P < 0.001). P(osm) and T(osm) decreased during exercise on FI and returned to preexercise values the following morning. The mean correlation between Tosm and Posm was r = 0.93 and that between USG and Posm was r = 0.72.
The conclusions of this study were that
·         Tear osmolarity increased with dehydration and tracked alterations in plasma osmolality
·         It seems that this new tear collection and analysis device offers a practical and rapid hydration assessment technique.